The iPhone 17 Pro has wowed us with its superior digital camera setup, it is blistering efficiency and, sure, its fiery-hot new orange color. However it’s not the one elite phone competing for the lofty title of digital camera champion. Removed from it, pal. Samsung’s flagship Android telephone, the Galaxy S25 Ultra, has impressed us many times with its pictures expertise, taking over all comers with the kind of reckless confidence I get solely after a number of rounds of piña coladas. Yum.
To see how these two elite picture telephones carry out, I took them out on a number of image-capturing missions round Edinburgh, testing them in a wide range of situations after which scrutinizing the outcomes. On that word, it is essential to needless to say with telephones at this degree, there usually will not be a ‘winner’ in every check. Many outcomes will come down to non-public choice, and certainly that is very a lot the case right here.
Watch this: iPhone Air, One Month Later: Digicam and Battery Worries Put to Relaxation
Learn extra: Best Camera Phone of 2025
As a professional photographer, I like a extra true-to-life picture, with pure tones and wealthy distinction that give me a superb baseline to use my very own edits ought to I need to. I additionally don’t love over-processing that may make a picture look too digital and synthetic. A few of you might disagree, preferring as an alternative extra vibrant photos with robust saturation and readability that may be shared on to social with none further effort in your half. Both stance is okay, but it surely’s why exams like these have to be taken with a pinch of salt.
With that mentioned, let’s dive in and check out the photographs. All pictures had been taken in every telephone’s normal digital camera app in JPEG (or HEIF for a number of the iPhone’s photos) and have been imported and resized in Adobe Lightroom, however with no further edits or sharpening utilized.
Do not miss any of our unbiased tech content material and lab-based opinions. Add CNET as a most well-liked Google supply.
iPhone 17 Professional vs. Galaxy S25 Extremely: Predominant digital camera exams
iPhone 17 Professional, essential digital camera.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, essential digital camera.
Like every common day of mine, this check begins with loads of bread and melted cheese. Each pictures look nice, with nice element and a fair publicity. The colours on the S25 Extremely are marginally richer, which I do not thoughts right here because it helps the meals actually pop.
iPhone 17 Professional, essential digital camera.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, essential digital camera.
Exterior within the Autumn mild, I really like the colours captured by each telephones. The iPhone’s picture has richer distinction, with deeper black ranges that I feel look higher, however in any other case there’s little or no to decide on between them.
iPhone 17 Professional, essential digital camera.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, essential digital camera.
Ditto once I bought shut up on this leaf. I feel the iPhone’s bokeh (the out-of-focus background) appears to be like slightly nicer, however I barely desire the deeper tones on the S25 Extremely. (These are true optical bokeh, not portrait-mode type processing.) Toss a coin and select your favourite.
iPhone 17 Professional, essential digital camera.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, essential digital camera.
There is a a lot larger distinction right here, although. Whereas the publicity is comparable, the S25 Extremely’s colours are considerably extra saturated than the iPhone’s — discover the blue boat hull and the reddish constructing on the proper. Is that good? Effectively, that once more comes all the way down to opinion. To my eye, Samsung’s shot appears to be like overly saturated to the purpose of wanting fairly faux. I a lot desire the extra muted, virtually filmic tones of the iPhone.
iPhone 17 Professional, ultrawide digital camera.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, ultrawide digital camera.
And it is virtually precisely the identical story once I switched to the ultrawide cameras of each telephones. The S25 Extremely delivered a extremely saturated picture whereas the iPhone’s is way more delicate.
iPhone 17 Professional, essential digital camera.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, essential digital camera.
The Galaxy S25 Extremely has finished a greater job right here, although, color-wise, with hotter, extra autumnal tones that swimsuit the scene effectively. The iPhone’s shot appears to be like slightly chilly by comparability.
iPhone 17 Professional (left) vs. Galaxy S25 Extremely (proper) 200% element crop
However simply to confuse the outcome, whereas the iPhone’s colours won’t look as good, once I regarded shut up on the particulars across the edge, I seen that its shot has noticeably higher readability, whereas the S25 Extremely’s picture has misplaced loads of element. Will you ever discover that distinction? Virtually actually not, particularly if you happen to’re solely posting to Instagram or sending over WhatsApp, however when each telephones are over $1,000, you’d higher consider I will nitpick more durable than you ever thought potential.
iPhone 17 Professional, essential digital camera.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, essential digital camera.
That mentioned, I really haven’t got so much to say between these two pictures inside a museum in Edinburgh. Each are effectively uncovered and whereas the iPhone has leant right into a barely extra magenta white steadiness, I do not actually see that as both a superb or a foul factor. Take your decide.
iPhone 17 Professional, ultrawide digital camera.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, ultrawide digital camera.
I positively desire the iPhone’s shot when switching to the ultrawide lens, although. The S25 Extremely has evidently tried to tug down the highlights on the reflection on the ground, leaving it wanting slightly gloomy. The ground pops extra within the iPhone’s shot, which provides nicer distinction to the scene general.
iPhone 17 Professional, essential digital camera.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, essential digital camera.
This is one other instance of extra vibrant tones from the S25 Extremely with the iPhone’s wanting extra pure. I do know which I desire (the iPhone, if you have not been paying consideration), however there’s nothing flawed with the S25 Extremely’s shot both.
iPhone 17 Professional, essential digital camera.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, essential digital camera.
And on this picture wanting up at some golden leaves, I can see virtually no discernible distinction in anyway. Beautiful stuff.
iPhone 17 Professional, essential digital camera.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, essential digital camera.
The iPhone’s shot is certainly a lot brighter right here and it appears to be like higher for it. I do not actually know why the S25 Extremely has underexposed its picture, but it surely’s made the scene look fairly drab because of this.
iPhone 17 Professional vs. Galaxy S25 Extremely: Zoom pictures
Each telephones have devoted optical zoom lenses, with the iPhone’s going as much as 8x (what Apple calls “optical high quality,” which is a processed crop of the 48-megapixel sensor) and the S25 Extremely going barely additional to 10X. Each telephones supply totally different preset zoom ranges in between.
iPhone 17 Professional, 8x zoom.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, 10x zoom.
Beginning at 8x on the iPhone and 10x on the Galaxy, this shot of golden leaves appears to be like nice on each, with vibrant tones and stable particulars.
iPhone 17 Professional, 4x zoom.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, 5x zoom.
Whereas at 4x zoom on the iPhone and 5x on the S25 Extremely, I once more assume that each telephones have finished a fantastic job. The iPhone has leaned barely more durable into hotter autumnal tones, with the greens of the grass and leaves wanting extra vibrant and emerald within the S25 Extremely’s picture.
iPhone 17 Professional, 4x zoom.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, 5x zoom.
At 5x zoom, the Galaxy S25 Extremely’s picture appears to be like fairly uninteresting and underexposed, with a slight magenta shift to its colours. The iPhone’s shot at 4x zoom appears to be like brighter, with nicer-looking colours.
iPhone 17 Professional, 8x zoom.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, 10x zoom.
And it is a lot the identical on the full 8x and 10x zoom ranges; higher distinction and colours from the iPhone.
I’ve discovered the Galaxy can battle with its colours extra when zooming than when utilizing the primary digital camera. Take this for instance:
iPhone 17 Professional, essential digital camera.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, essential digital camera.
At the usual focal size of the primary digital camera these photos are virtually equivalent, with lovely heat tones captured by each telephones.
iPhone 17 Professional, 2x zoom.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, 2x zoom.
However zooming in to 2x has actually thrown the Galaxy off. Its white steadiness as an alternative errs on colder tones with extra of a magenta bias, dropping that pretty golden mild that is nonetheless current within the iPhone’s picture.
iPhone 17 Professional, 8x zoom.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, 10x zoom.
However then I desire the hotter coloration tones of the Galaxy’s 10x zoom on this instance. The tree leaves look noticeably extra heat and wealthy.
iPhone 17 Professional, 8x zoom.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, 10x zoom.
And once more on the iPhone’s 8x zoom and the S25 Extremely at 10x, there is a huge coloration shift. The iPhone’s picture appears to be like extra cyan-toned general — and I feel it has barely higher distinction too.
iPhone 17 Professional, 8x zoom.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, 10x zoom.
On the identical zoom lengths, I am once more seeing extra of a cyan shift within the white steadiness on the iPhone and a brighter, extra contrasty scene general. For my style, I desire the iPhone, however the S25 Extremely’s remains to be technically stable.
It is fascinating to see how every telephone performs higher in several eventualities, virtually there’s virtually no rhyme or cause I can see as to why. In some zoom photos, the iPhone appears to be like hotter and richer, different instances the S25 does. It makes it very tough for me as a tech author to think about both one a winner although, because it largely comes down to non-public choice.
iPhone 17 Professional vs. Galaxy S25 Extremely: Evening mode
iPhone 17 Professional, essential digital camera, night time mode.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, essential digital camera, night time mode.
Switching to nighttime mode on the primary digital camera, the iPhone’s picture is noticeable brighter (significantly within the cobbled road and the sky) though that slight cyan shift is now within the S25 Extremely’s picture. The S25’s shot can also be marginally sharper, however you’ve got actually bought to zoom in near see the distinction.
iPhone 17 Professional, essential digital camera, night time mode.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, essential digital camera, night time mode.
And it is a comparable story right here. The iPhone’s shot is brighter within the sky and with noticeably much less picture noise, however the particulars on the buildings are a lot clearer on the S25 Extremely’s picture.
iPhone 17 Professional (left) vs. Galaxy S25 Extremely, 100% element crop.
If we crop proper in on the main points, it is clear to see that the Galaxy S25 Extremely has the sting relating to readability, however the iPhone’s picture has stronger colours.
iPhone 17 Professional, ultrawide digital camera, night time mode.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, ultrawide digital camera, night time mode.
The conclusion is similar within the ultrawide mode too, though each telephones have delivered a a lot darker shot. Ultrawide night time mode nonetheless has some solution to go, whatever the telephone you select.
iPhone 17 Professional, 8x zoom, night time mode.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, 10x zoom, night time mode.
And at 8x and 10x zoom on the iPhone and Galaxy respectively, the Galaxy once more wins relating to readability, however the iPhone’s colours look a lot better.
iPhone 17 Professional vs. Galaxy S25 Extremely: Selfie check
iPhone 17 Professional, selfie digital camera.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, selfie digital camera.
There was no means I used to be going to publish this many pictures with out placing my very own huge silly face on the web page someplace. And I’ve to say the iPhone has finished a far superior job in capturing mentioned face. The publicity is brighter with higher distinction, the colours are hotter and punchier, and the main points are higher too. The S25 Extremely’s picture appears to be like actually quite drab compared.
iPhone 17 Professional, selfie digital camera, vast mode.
Galaxy S25 Extremely, selfie digital camera, vast mode.
And once I activated every telephone’s wide-angle selfie mode, the iPhone once more got here out on high. The higher publicity, distinction and colours are nonetheless the case, but it surely additionally affords a a lot wider view than the S25 Extremely can handle. This might be useful if you happen to’re attempting to squash a great deal of your pals into the scene or, like me, good if you wish to present loads of further house round you the place mates might be if you happen to’d bothered to make any or speak to anybody outdoors of the office.
iPhone 17 Professional vs. Samsung Galaxy S25 Extremely: Which has the higher digital camera?
After many check pictures taken, miles walked and tens of millions of pixels peeped at on display screen, I can lastly conclude that the perfect digital camera telephone between the iPhone 17 Professional and the Galaxy S25 Extremely is…drumroll please…
You resolve.
Is that the perfect I can do based mostly on my 14 years of expertise as tech journalist and photographer? Truthfully, sure. Each telephones have carried out extraordinarily effectively in these exams, and neither one can actually be thought-about objectively higher than the opposite in any main means. The S25 Extremely, like virtually all of Samsung’s telephones, tends to lean extra towards extremely saturated colours, whereas the iPhone retains issues a bit extra pure. At night time, the Galaxy is sharper, however the iPhone has higher colours. Typically the iPhone’s zoom pictures regarded richer, whereas different instances the S25 Extremely’s zoom photos had been preferable.
Preferable to me, anyway. As I discussed in the beginning of this check, I take a extra delicate method with my pictures, preferring a pure base picture that provides me extra scope for making use of my very own edits in apps like Adobe Lightroom or Google’s Snapseed. The iPhone 17 Professional stays my most well-liked digital camera telephone for that cause, however lots of you’ll doubtless love the punchier look supplied by the Galaxy telephone. The one space the iPhone actually got here out on high is with the entrance digital camera, so if high-quality gurning selfies are your factor, go together with the iPhone.
Actually, both telephone is an absolute cracker relating to pictures, and it actually should not come all the way down to digital camera efficiency if you happen to’re struggling to resolve whether or not to go Android or iOS.
